← Back to News
October 10, 2026 · News · By Young Hadene

Alberta Court to Ottawa: Your Assessment Law Is Still Unconstitutional

Key Takeaways

  • Alberta Court of Appeal: revised federal assessment law still unconstitutional.
  • Follows the Supreme Court's 2023 strike-down of the original.
  • Another top-court showdown likely.

Alberta's Court of Appeal has ruled Ottawa's Impact Assessment Act is still unconstitutional — even after the feds rewrote it following the Supreme Court's 2023 demolition of the original.

Ottawa vs. Edmonton, forever

The court says the revised law still tramples provincial jurisdiction over resources and environment. Expect another Supreme Court chapter in the endless federation stress test.

Why Toronto should care

Every pipeline, port and housing mega-project in the 6ix lives or dies on these same assessment rules. When Alberta and Ottawa fight over who approves what, Toronto builds slower and pays more.

Sources: CBC News. Context from the Young Hadene newsroom.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the court rule?

That Ottawa's rewritten Impact Assessment Act still infringes provincial jurisdiction.

What happens next?

Likely another Supreme Court of Canada battle.